欢迎访问《北京师范大学学报》(社会科学版),今天是

北京师范大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2019, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (5): 118-127.

• 哲学反思 • 上一篇    下一篇

人性的结构与目的论善性——荀子人性论再论

李景林   

  1. 北京师范大学 哲学学院,北京 100875
  • 收稿日期:2019-05-26 出版日期:2019-09-25 发布日期:2019-11-04
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金重大项目“中国传统价值观变迁史”(14ZDB003)。

The Structure of Human Nature and Teleological Goodness: The re-discussion of Xunzi's theory of human nature

LI Jinglin   

  1. School of Philosophy,BNU,Beijing 100875,China
  • Received:2019-05-26 Online:2019-09-25 Published:2019-11-04

摘要: 后儒对荀子的批评,主要集中在其“性恶论”。荀子论人性的结构,强调人的实存活动及其情欲要求必受制于心知及其抉择之支配,据“心之所可”以规定其实现的途径与行为的原则,由之而获得其正面(善)或负面(非善或恶)的道德价值和意义,而非直接现成地顺自然而行。荀子针对孟子的性善论而言“性恶”,其实质是强调人性中本无“现成的善”,而非言人性中具有“实质的恶”。荀子善言“类”,以为人之类性及理或道规定了其存在之终极目的,故人作为一个“类”的存在,本内在地具有一种自身趋赴于善的逻辑必然性或目的论意义之善性。是以其在政治上并未导致外在强制之说,在道德上亦主张自力成德,而未导致他力的救赎说。其政治伦理哲学的体系,亦由此而获得了一种终始相扣的理论自洽性。人的实存“从心之所可”的人性结构论与目的论的善性说,共同构成了荀子人性论学说的整体内涵。

关键词: 性恶, 实质之恶, 人性内容, 人性结构, 目的论善性, 理论自洽

Abstract: The theory “evil of human nature” has been the criticism focus on Xunzi by the later scholars of the Confucius school. When talk about the structure of human nature,Xunzi emphasized that person's actual activities and emotional requirements shall be subject to the mind and it choice. The rules controlled by mind decide the implementation ways and behavior principle,add positive (good)or negative (not good or evil)moral value and significance in practical situations,rather than cause behaviors directly from the good or evil nature. In view of Mencius's “theory of original goodness of human nature”,Xunzi raised “evil of human nature”,whose essence is to emphasize there is no “ready goodness” in human nature,rather than to illustrate human nature is essentially “evil”. Xunzi held that human beings should be regarded as the same kind,whose nature is named as “dao” or “li”,which provides the ultimate existence purpose for human beings. As the existence as a “kind”,human beings have the tendency to be good,because of the logical inevitability and teleological goodness. Therefore,it did not relay on the external force in politics and in moral,but advocated self-reliance to achieve the moral goal. Both the structure of human nature of “subject to the mind” and the teleological goodness of nature formed the overall connotation of Xunzi's theory of human nature.

Key words: evil of human nature, essential evil, connotation of human nature, structure of human nature, teleological goodness of nature, self-consistent in theory

中图分类号: