欢迎访问《北京师范大学学报》(社会科学版),今天是

北京师范大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2020, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (3): 29-41.

• 教育论坛 • 上一篇    下一篇

从同行承认到规范推荐—开放评价引发的开放科学革命与人才制度革命

刘益东   

  1. 中国科学院 自然科学史研究所,北京 100190
  • 收稿日期:2020-02-10 发布日期:2020-12-11

From Peer Recognition to Standard Recommendation:Open scientific revolution and talent system revolution triggered by the open review

LIU Yidong   

  1. Institute for the History of Natural Science,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100190,China
  • Received:2020-02-10 Published:2020-12-11

摘要: 为克服同行评议和文献计量法的根本缺陷,作者于15年前提出开放评价法这一替代方案。经过不断改进,迄今在实现学术评价客观化方面又有新的进展。为了突破同行承认是硬通货这一金科玉律,让非共识的原创、突破、颠覆性创新成果及时胜出,让原创人才、颠覆性创新人才及时胜出并充分发挥作用,建议用规范推荐取代通行的同行承认。这一主张基于程序公信、评价结果可重复的开放评价原则,它会使包括用户在内的外行评价成为可能,由此形成真正的学术市场和思想市场。工业革命形成经济市场实现了人类创造力的第一次大解放,让拥有商业才能者如鱼得水;开放科学革命将形成有效的学术市场和思想市场,实现人类创造力的第二次大解放,它会使拥有学术才能者如虎添翼,新型科研机构、教育机构如工业革命之后的公司企业,迅速崛起,纵横天下。率先发动和实现开放科学革命和人才制度革命的国家、地区与机构,将在吸引、保持拔尖人才方面赢得先机和优势。

关键词: 开放评价, 开放科学, 规范推荐, 人才制度, 人才秩序, 科学革命

Abstract: In order to overcome the shortcomings of peer review and bibliometrics,the author proposed open evaluation as an alternative method fifteen years ago.After continuous improvement,there has been new progress in the objectification of academic evaluation.With the purpose to break the golden rule of peer recognition,it is recommended that normative recommendations replace prevailing peer recognition,which will enable the disputable original works,breakthroughs and revolutionary innovations to surpass and the creative and revolutionary talents to give their full play.The implementation of the open evaluation based on procedures credibility and repeatable evaluation results will make valuation from nonprofessionals such as the users possible;thus,a genuine academic and ideological market will be formed.The economic market formed by the industrial revolution realized the first great liberation of human creativity,making those with business aptitudes give full scope to their talents.Likewise,the open scientific revolution will form an effective academic and ideological market and realize the second great liberation of human creativity.Those with academic talents may become more powerful and new types of scientific and educational institutions may rise rapidly and become global players,just like companies after the industrial revolution.The countries,regions and institutions that take the lead in launching and realizing the open scientific revolution and talent system revolution will win more opportunities and advantages in attracting and maintaining top talents.

Key words: open review, open science, normative recommendation, talent system, order of talents, scientific revolution

中图分类号: