欢迎访问《北京师范大学学报》(社会科学版),今天是

北京师范大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2019, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (2): 38-51.

• 教育论坛 • 上一篇    下一篇

更多的教育投入能带来更好的教育吗?

成刚   

  1. 北京师范大学 教育学部/首都教育经济研究院,北京 100875
  • 出版日期:2019-03-25 发布日期:2019-03-25
  • 基金资助:
    2017年北京社科基金研究基地项目“优质均衡背景下北京市义务教育资源配置结构、共享和效益研究”(17JDYJB024),北京市社会科学研究基金项目“政府教育财政努力程度研究”(16JDJYB006),2013年国家社科基金青年项目“内涵式发展视角下的我国高校规模、结构、质量与办学效率研究”(13CGL121),2018年度北京师范大学教育学部青年教师科研项目“民族地区教育精准扶贫绩效评价研究”。

Will More Input Bring about Better Education?

CHENG Gang 1,2   

  1. 1.Faculty of Education,BNU,Beijing 100875;
    2.Capital Institute of Economic Education Research,Beijing 100875,China
  • Online:2019-03-25 Published:2019-03-25

摘要: 随着新时代我国社会主要矛盾的变化,期盼“更好的教育”成为教育改革发展的出发点和落脚点。长期以来,政府教育投入不足一直被认为是教育不够好的主要原因,但政策实践和理论研究并没有发现仅靠增加教育投入就能带来更好的教育,这可能意味着,教育投入结构及其使用组织和管理也非常重要。从深入剖析教育的基本功能入手,并在区分教育的直接产出和间接产出的基础上所进行的经验研究表明:第一,教育投入多的区域并不一定能有更好的教育。原因在于,优质教育资源聚集的地区由于承载力不足,带来学校规模小、效益低等问题;而农村或偏远地区人口分散、空间距离远,承载力过剩,导致教育供给成本高,且浪费严重。对此,在政策选择上一方面应着力优化区域空间结构,严格限制城市规模,匹配性地限制城市常住人口数量与在校学生数量,从而提供公平而有质量的教育;另一方面,应积极落实党的十九大提出的乡村振兴战略和区域协调发展,加快农村人口城镇化进程,完善人口转移机制。第二,从教育投入的结构来看,要想获得“更好的教育”,办学条件的影响最大,这也反映出新时代我国义务教育发展进入到新阶段,办学条件标准“一刀切”,但执行中弹性太大,优质学校达标困难。为此应加快研究制定小规模学校办学条件标准,因地制宜,全面加强乡村小规模学校和乡镇寄宿制学校建设,保证小规模学校的基本办学条件,切实加强可移动的和对教育质量贡献度大的资源配置,保证必要教育教学活动的全面开展。第三,教育的产出是多方面、综合性的,现实中甚至会出现不同产出之间的矛盾,因此必须清晰判断“更好的教育”需要哪类教育产出。研究发现,要想获得“更好的教育”,与教育产出的经济效益相比,社会效益更为重要——这主要表现在学校的服务半径和所提供的学位数方面。由于低龄儿童的特殊性,义务教育规定就近入学,就近入学凸显了学校服务半径和学位数的重要性。虽然两基达标解决了人人有学上的问题,但随着人民群众对更好教育需求的日益增长,教育发展不平衡不充分日益明显,如何让老百姓就近公平地享受优质教育资源取决于合理的划片,而合理的划片有赖学校的服务半径和学校提供学位的能力。

关键词: 教育投入, 教育产出, 更好的教育, 绩效

Abstract: “The pursuit of better education” has become the starting point and the foothold of education reforms in concordance with the changes in the principal contradictions our society faces in the new era,and inadequate government investment has long been regarded as the main cause for discontented education.However,the policy application and theoretical research indicate that more investment has not brought about the ideal result,which means the investment structure and its management is equally important.Based on the comprehensive analysis of the basic functions of education and its direct and indirect outputs,the empirical research shows that: first,districts with more investment may not necessarily have better education,because of the small scale or poor efficiency caused by the low education carrying capacity in these districts.By contrast,districts in rural or remote areas are facing surplus carrying capacity because of dispersed population and farther distance,which leads to high cost and serious waste of education supply.Therefore,one the one hand,we should focus on optimizing the spatial structure and providing fair and quality education by strictly limiting the scale of cities and matching the numbers of permanent residents and students in school and on the other hand,we should fully apply the requirements proposed by the 19th CPC National Congress on the rural revitalization strategy and regional coordinated development by speeding up urbanization and improving the population transfer mechanism.Second,the condition of school is the most influential factor to realize “better education” in the whole structure of education investment,which also reflects the shortcomings of one-size-fits-all standard in a new stage of compulsory education in the new era.In order to ensure the basic condition of small schools,it is necessary to speed up the formulation of the standards for small schools,and make efforts to strengthen the construction of small and boarding schools in villages.Additionally,we should strengthen the allocation of movable and most beneficial resources to ensure the comprehensive implementation of educational and teaching activities.Third,the education output is multi-faceted and comprehensive,and contradictions among different kinds of outputs may arise in reality,so we should judge which function is most desirable for “better education”.The study finds that social benefits,including school's service radius and the admissible number of students,are more important than the economic benefits.In the compulsory education,“nearby enrollment policy” is conducted for the benefits of the young aged students,which highlights the importance of the service radius and admissible number of students.Although the policy has provided the opportunity for every student to receive education,it cannot meet the people's demand for better education,and the contradiction between growing demand and the imbalanced education resources has become increasingly obvious.Whether people can enjoy the quality education resources fairly and nearly depends on the school district division,which is decided by the service radius of schools and their admissible capacity of students.

Key words: education investment, education output, better education, performance

中图分类号: