欢迎访问《北京师范大学学报》(社会科学版),今天是

北京师范大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2024, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (5): 72-84.

• 哲学史研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

近代国家理论的三条进路及其革命性变革

鉴博言   

  1. 北京航空航天大学 马克思主义学院,北京 100191
  • 出版日期:2024-09-25 发布日期:2024-11-27
  • 作者简介:鉴博言,哲学博士,北京航空航天大学马克思主义学院博士后。

Three Approaches to the Modern Theory of States and Its Revolutionary Transformation

JIAN Boyan   

  1. School of Marxism,Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics,Beijing 100191,China
  • Online:2024-09-25 Published:2024-11-27

摘要: 从国家与其所处的社会整体的关系来看,近代政治哲学传统中的国家理论大致可以分为三种进路:以霍布斯、卢梭为代表的传统政治学理论,在自然法和契约论的张力中论证国家和政治秩序的法理基础;以苏格兰启蒙学者为代表的政治经济学理论,在经济和市民社会的壮大中探索商业社会的国家职能;以黑格尔、李斯特为代表的德国历史哲学理论,在前两者的基础上,试图以国家解决现代性社会转型带来的矛盾问题。这三种进路各自聚焦现代国家的不同侧面,也因而展现出不同的社会观基础,其理论意识都源于如何定位近代社会转型中的国家及其职能的思考。但是,它们都潜在地采用“国家—社会”的二分理论预设,而这一历史前提本身需要被思考,才能更好地把握现代国家的运作机理。马克思、恩格斯奠定的历史唯物主义国家理论超越了这种二分范式,主张在社会结构中对国家进行历史性的考察,实现了国家理论的范式转换。

关键词: 国家理论, 现代性, 社会转型, 现代国家

Abstract: In terms of the relationship between states and their social structures,the theory of states in the modern political philosophy can be divided into three approaches. The first one is the traditional theory of political science represented by Hobbes and Rousseau,and it argues for the jurisprudential foundations of state political order between the natural law and the contractualism. The second one is the theory of political economy represented by the Scottish Enlightenment scholars and it explores states' functions in the growth of economy and civil society. And the third one is the German philosophical theory of history represented by Hegel and Liszt and it,based on the former two,attempts to use states to resolve the contradictions brought about by the transformation of modern society. Each of these three approaches focuses on a different aspect of modern states,and therefore,displays a different foundation of social outlook,with their theoretical consciousness originating from how to locate states and their functions in the transformation of modern society. However,they all adopt the dichotomous presupposition of “state/society”,and the historical premise itself needs examining to better grasp the functioning mechanisms of modern states. The historical materialist theory of states laid down by Marx and Engels transcends this dichotomous paradigm by advocating a historical perspective of states in the context of social structures,thus realizing a paradigm shift in the theory of states.

Key words: the theory of states, modernity, social transformation, modern states

中图分类号: