欢迎访问《北京师范大学学报》(社会科学版),今天是

北京师范大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2019, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (5): 100-107.

• 史学前沿 • 上一篇    下一篇

王霸政治的历史经验与现实参照——崔寔政治思想再探

把梦阳   

  1. 上海大学 文学院历史系,上海 200444
  • 收稿日期:2019-01-26 出版日期:2019-09-25 发布日期:2019-11-04

The Historical Experience and Realistic Reference of “Wang” and “Ba” Politics: A re-exploration of CUI Shi's political thoughts

BA Mengyang   

  1. Department of History,College of Liberal Arts,Shanghai University,Shanghai 200444,China
  • Received:2019-01-26 Online:2019-09-25 Published:2019-11-04

摘要: 东汉后期,针对政治腐败、法令废弛的末世之象,崔寔提出统治者应通过“参以霸政”的手段来解决政治困局。显然,此论与汉儒尊崇王道的主流观点格格不入,因而古今学者对崔寔的评价,无论批评或肯定,大都基于儒法之争、王霸之辩的传统视角。其实,在崔寔的语境中,所谓霸道,既是一种针对两汉以来政治文化发展困局,亦即“百王之敝”的解决途径,也是对正统儒家所倡导的王道思想之不足的弥补,因而并不应将崔寔所论之“霸”完全视为王道的对立面。为了论证霸道的正当性,崔寔还借助春秋时期的诸侯尊王攘夷、奉行霸政这一历史经验,来说明具有强权性质的“霸”之手段,亦能在帝国现实政治的情境下发挥重要作用。可见,崔寔之论,既非一味地尊霸而非王,亦非简单的王霸并用,而是试图援引霸道中的某些具体因素来救补王道。

关键词: 崔寔, 《政论》, “百王之敝”, 王与霸, 历史与现实

Abstract: In the late Eastern Han Dynasty,CUI Shi advocated the “goverance in the way of Ba (law and penalty)” to solve the problem of “the political defects of hundreds of kings”,to confront with the apocalyptic situation of corrupted politics and deposed laws. It was inconsistent with the mainstream view of the scholars of his times,who supported the way of Wang (morality and mercifulness),so the ancient and modern scholars' evaluation of CUI Wei,whether critical or supportive,was based on the academic debates between Confucians and the law school,as well as the traditional perspective of the arguments for the ways of Wang or Ba. In CUI Shi's context,the way of Ba provided a possible solution not only to the political and cultural dilemmas of the Western and Eastern Han Dynasties and the problem of “the political defect of hundreds of kings”,but also to the shortcomings of the way of Wang,advocated by the traditional Confucians;therefore,the way of Ba should not be simply regarded as the opposite of Wang. In order to justify the way of Ba,CUI Shi also used the historical experience of the King of Zhou in fighting the barbarism in the Spring and Autumn Period to demonstrate the benefit of Ba to imperial politics. It can be seen that CUI Shi's viewpoint was not to support the way of Ba,nor to use both Wang and Ba,but to try to introduce the positive elements of the way of Ba to assist that of Wang.

Key words: CUI Shi, Zhenglun (political comments), the political defect of hundreds of kings, the ways of Wang and Ba, history and reality

中图分类号: