欢迎访问《北京师范大学学报》(社会科学版),今天是

北京师范大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2020, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (2): 98-104.

• 史学前沿——学术思想史研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

试论春秋笔法及其历史书写中的客观性

骆扬   

  1. 陕西师范大学 历史文化学院,西安 710062
  • 收稿日期:2019-07-20 出版日期:2020-03-25 发布日期:2020-12-07
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金一般项目“《春秋》经传历史书写之史学理论研究”(19BZS001)。

The Style of The Spring and Autumn Annals and the Objectivity of Its Historical Writing

LUO Yang   

  1. School of History and Civilization,Shaanxi Normal University,Xi'an 710119,China
  • Received:2019-07-20 Online:2020-03-25 Published:2020-12-07

摘要: 传统的观点认为春秋笔法是孔子设立褒贬的标准,是一种历史书写主观意识的体现。然而《春秋》的书写中本就包含了两个层面:一是反映客观历史的,即曾经发生过的史事;二是反映主观意识的,即书写者的主观判断。历史文本是主体(书写者)与所记录客观对象(史事)结合的产物,这两者之间存在着一种张力。《春秋》对史事的记录是经过判断的结果。而史官(孔子)的判断又分为两个层次:一是对史实的认定,即客观史事首先要经过史官主观的分析与决断,是书写者所认定的客观真实,但其认定的事实受礼法传统的影响,要理解他们对客观真实的认识不应超越那个时代的意义体系;二是史官的书写规则,即把经过分析认定的事实用合适的语言表达出来。而这也在长期的历史传统中客体化为春秋笔法,是那个时代历史观念的一种客观体现,在史官传统及主体间的相互认同中不断得以固化和加强,是历史真实赖以存在的条件。在《春秋》的书写中,史官并非不注重历史记录的客观真实性,但他们试图通过凸显自身主体性的方式更好地展示心中的历史之真。这种主观意识来源并受限于客观存在的历史传统,其背后体现了时代的客观合理性。所以,春秋笔法是一种书写客观历史之真的特殊总结。

关键词: 《春秋》, 春秋笔法, 历史书写, 客观性

Abstract: The “writing style of Chunqiu (The Spring and Autumn Annals)” is usually regarded as the evaluation standard set up by Confucius,an embodiment of the subjective consciousness of historical writing.However,there are two aspects reflected in the writing of Chunqiu.One is to reflect the objective history,that is,the historical events that had taken place.The other is to reflect the subjective consciousness,that is,the writer's subjective judgment.The historical text is the combination of the subject (the writer)and the object (recorded historical events),and there is a tension between those two aspects.The record of historical events in Chunqiu is the result of writer's judgment.The judgment of historian (Confucius in this case)can be divided into two levels.One is the confirmation of historical facts,which means the historical events must first be subjectively analyzed and judged by the historian,but the historians' recognition is inevitably influenced by the cultural tradition,so their understanding of objective truth could not exceed the meaning system of the historical period.The other is the writing rules of the historian,which means the facts analyzed and confirmed by the historians should be expressed in appropriate words.This is also objectified as the writing style of Chunqiu in the long-term historical tradition,which is an objective embodiment of the historical concept in that period.It was solidified and strengthened in the mutual recognition among the historians,which provided the condition for the existence of historical reality.The historians paid less attention to the objective authenticity of historical records in the writing of Chunqiu,but tried to better represent the truth of history in their minds by highlighting their own subjectivity.This subjective consciousness comes from and is limited by the historical tradition,which reflects the objective rationality of that historical period.Therefore,the writing style of Chunqiu is a special way to record the truth of objective history.

Key words: Chunqiu (The Spring and Autumn Annals), the writing style of Chunqiu, historical writing, objectivity

中图分类号: