欢迎访问《北京师范大学学报》(社会科学版),今天是

北京师范大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2021, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (1): 88-100.

• 哲学反思 • 上一篇    下一篇

论默隐证据——关于哲学思辨研究方法论的一种思考

苏君阳   

  1. 北京师范大学 教育学部,北京 100875
  • 发布日期:2021-02-07
  • 作者简介:苏君阳,教育学博士,北京师范大学教育学部教授。

On Tacit Evidence:A reflection on the methodology of philosophical speculation

SU Junyang   

  1. Faculty of Education,BNU,Beijing 100875,China
  • Published:2021-02-07

摘要: 实证主义研究范式兴起后,哲学思辨研究常因其主观性问题而遭受人们诟病。实证主义研究本质就是利用收集到的信息与数据去探究与发现新的事物或事物间的相互关系,对于哲学思辨研究而言亦应如此。在哲学思辨研究中很多信息与数据都是默隐的,默隐证据是哲学思辨研究一种重要的证据方式。默隐证据的应用是哲学思辨研究表达的需要,它包括需要表达但无法给予表达与能够表达但不需要表达两种类型。默隐证据的适用有利于提升抽象一般性问题的研究价值,使价值问题的论证具有了可能以及人文社会科学话语表达更为经济,也有利于进一步提升人类思维的理性化水平。但是,默隐证据适用过程中容易使得人们产生文本意义理解上的障碍,让人们在文本阅读中产生理解上的偏见与歧义,容易造成研究者主观随意以及空疏论辩之风的形成。默隐证据在哲学思辨研究中的价值是不可否认的,同时应谨防与杜绝其在人文社会科学研究中的误用与滥用。

关键词: 默隐证据, 哲学思辨, 对象性知识, 对象化知识, 方法论

Abstract: After the rise of positivism paradigm,philosophical speculative research has been criticized for its subjectivity.The essence of positivism research is to make use of information and data collected to explore and discover new things or the relationship between things,which should be the same for philosophical speculative research.As for the latter,a lot of information and data are tacit,and such tacit evidence serves as an important type of evidence in philosophical speculative research.The application of tacit evidence is of vital necessity for the expression of philosophical speculative research.There are two types of tacit evidence:those which need to but cannot be expressed and those which can but do not need to be expressed.The application of tacit evidence is conducive to enhance the research value of abstract general problems,to make the demonstration of value issues possible,to make the discourse expression of humanities and social sciences more economical,and to further improve the rational level of human thinking.However,in the process of applying tacit evidence,people are prone to encounter obstacles in understanding the meaning of texts,which not only leads to bias or ambiguity when reading,but also gives rise to researchers' subjective arbitrariness,as well as empty and shallow debates.The value of tacit evidence in philosophical speculative research is undeniable,and we should guard against its misuse and abuse in the research of humanities and social sciences.

Key words: tacit evidence, philosophical speculation, objective knowledge, objectified knowledge, methodology

中图分类号: