欢迎访问《北京师范大学学报》(社会科学版),今天是

北京师范大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2022, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (5): 126-137.

• 哲学史研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

朱子学的“求真是”与“护朱”之争——以陈栎《四书发明》为中心

许家星   

  1. 北京师范大学 价值与文化研究中心、哲学学院,北京 100875
  • 出版日期:2022-09-25 发布日期:2022-09-29
  • 作者简介:许家星,哲学博士,北京师范大学价值与文化研究中心、哲学学院教授。
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金项目(21VGQ018)。

The “Seeking Truth” of Zhuzi's Philosophy and Disputes about “Protecting Zhuzi's Philosophy”:Centered on CHEN Li's Four Books Interpretation

XU Jiaxing   

  1. School of Philosophy,BNU,Beijing 100875,China
  • Online:2022-09-25 Published:2022-09-29

摘要: 关于陈栎的“朱子世嫡”、“信朱子不如信饶氏”、朱学门户株守者的三种评价,折射出如何看待朱子后学对朱子学的继承与发展问题。就陈栎《四书发明》来看,它确实提出了诸多不同于朱子之见,其中除少量文字径直表达对朱子不满外,多数是通过引用他人之说表达对朱子的异议;它除采用张南轩不同于朱子之说外,还采取饶双峰对朱子的修正之解,从而体现了朱子学本有的“求真是”之精神。这引发了具有强烈护朱意识的史伯璿的指责,批评陈栎倒向双峰而背离朱子。这些不同的评价,体现了宋元以来朱子学中“求真是”与“护朱”两种不同解释立场之争,反映了朱子后学夹在“忠臣”与“佞臣”之间的内在张力。而坚守“求真是”之精神,正是超越这一“忠臣”与“妄议”分歧的关键。

关键词: 陈栎, 史伯璿, 饶双峰, 求真是, 护朱

Abstract: “A direct-line disciple of Zhuzi”,“a guardian of Zhuzi's Philosophy”,and “believing RAO Lu more than Zhuzi”,these three comments on CHEN Li reflect how to view the inheritance and development of Zhuzi Philosophy on the part of the later scholars of Zhuzi.But considering from the Fours Books Interpretation by CHEN Li,the book did put forward many ideas different from those of Zhuzi with a little direct expression of dissatisfaction with Zhuzi,and most of objections by means of quoting others' ideas.Apart from adopting different theories of ZHANG Nanxuan,the book proposed the amendment to Zhuzi by RAO Shuangfeng (RAO Lu) in particular,which shows the spirit of “seeking truth” of Zhuzi's Philosophy.But it aroused the criticism of SHI Boxuan with strong consciousness of protecting Zhuzi.SHI Boxuan criticized CHEN Li for his turning back to RAO Lu and deviating from Zhuzi to a certain extent.The different comments between scholars reflect the disputes of two different interpretations of the “seeking truth” of Zhuzi's Philosophy and “protecting Zhuzi's Philosophy” since Song and Yuan Dynasties.The different comments also reflect the internal tension between “loyal officials” and “sycophantic officials” among the later scholars of Zhuzi.Adherence to the spirit of “seeking truth” is the key to go beyond the divergence of “loyal officials” and “preposterous opinions”.

Key words: CHEN Li, SHI Boxuan, RAO Shuangfeng (RAO Lu), seeking truth, protecting Zhuzi's Philopophy

中图分类号: