欢迎访问《北京师范大学学报》(社会科学版),今天是

北京师范大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2023, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (5): 117-126.

• 中国古代史研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

隋炀帝首巡扬州史事考辨

马俊亚   

  1. 南京大学 历史学院,南京 210023
  • 出版日期:2023-09-25 发布日期:2023-10-23
  • 作者简介:马俊亚,历史学博士,南京大学历史学院教授。
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金重大招标项目“大运河与中国古代社会研究”(17ZDA184)。

A Study of the Historical Event of the First Visit to Yangzhou by Emperor Yang Guang of the Sui Dynasty

MA Junya   

  1. School of History, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210023, China
  • Online:2023-09-25 Published:2023-10-23

摘要: 唐、宋文献关于大业初年隋炀帝巡游扬州的史事过于违反常识。其中,仅五月余在扬州一地制造的包括龙舟在内的数万艘皇家豪华游船这一数据,相当于整个北宋每年造船能力的10倍以上;龙舟为超大型楼船,不能作为长途航运工具,且隋唐时由黄河、汴水、淮河、山阳渎组成的洛阳至扬州运道根本不能通行巨舶。隋炀帝船队龙舟的记载源于杜宝所撰《大业杂记》。一方面,在中国古代,后朝的政学人士惯于抹黑前朝帝王,夸大其骄奢淫糜做派,对末代君主尤甚;另一方面,《大业杂记》本质上是志异小说,不可作为信史。司马光撰《资治通鉴》,出于为宋代君主政治服务的目的,大量转录《大业杂记》中的无稽之言,遂致这些明显的史实谬误流传千年。

关键词: 隋炀帝, 通济渠(汴水), 山阳渎, 龙舟, 《大业杂记》, 《资治通鉴》

Abstract: In the literatures of the Tang and Song Dynasties,the records of the historical event of the first visit to Yangzhou by Emperor Yang Guang of the Sui Dynasty in the early years of Daye era (605-616) are too against common sense.Among them,the figure of tens of thousands of royal luxury pleasure boats,including dragon boats,manufactured in Yangzhou in just over five months,is more than ten times the annual shipbuilding capacity of the Northern Song Dynasty.The dragon boat is an extra-large pleasure boat (with many decks) and cannot be used as a long-distance shipping tool.Moreover,during the Sui and Tang Dynasties,the transportation route from Luoyang to Yangzhou,consisting of the Yellow River,Bianshui Canal,Huaihe River and Shanyangdu Canal,was impassable to giant boats at all.The record of Emperor Yang Guang's fleet of dragon boats originated from Du Bao's Daye Zaji.On the one hand,in ancient China,political scholars from later dynasties were accustomed to discrediting the previous emperors and exaggerating their extravagance and debauchery,especially towards the last monarchs.On the other hand,Daye Zaji is essentially a novel and cannot be used as a reliable historical resource.Sima Guang's Zizhi Tongjian with the aim of serving the monarchy of the Song Dynasty,extensively transcribing the absurd statements in Daye Zaji,thus causing these extremely glaring historical fallacies to spread for more than one thousand years.

Key words: Emperor Yang Guang of the Sui Dynasty, the Tongji Canal (Bianshui), the Shanyangdu Canal, dragon boat, Daye Zaji, Zizhi Tongjian

中图分类号: