父母冲突干预方案及对家庭和儿童青少年的影响

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 父母冲突会对儿童青少年的心理行为适应带来较为严重的消极影响,近年来旨在改善子女心理健康水平的父母冲突干预方案也越来越多。国内外相关的父母冲突干预方案大致可以分为针对离婚夫妻的干预项目和针对完整家庭的干预项目。这些干预方案有的侧重于说教和信息分享,有的侧重于技能训练;有的关注夫妻沟通和冲突解决,有的则关注父母共同养育。总体来说现有方案取得了良好的干预效果,但部分方案的研究设计仍不够严谨,或对方案如何起效缺少深入探讨。未来,我国的父母冲突干预研究可以开发更适用于中国家庭的干预方案,探索和开展对离异家庭的父母冲突预防性干预研究,采用多种研究方法以更系统地探讨父母冲突干预方案的效果、有效成分和作用机制。

关键词: 父母冲突, 干预方案, 离异家庭, 父母共同养育, 干预效果

Abstract: Inter-parental conflict has a severe negative effect on children's mental and behavioral adaption. Recently, more and more intervention programs in this regard have been developed to improve children's mental health, and the existent ones can be divided into two categories: programs for divorced families and for intact families. Some programs are didactic and focus on information sharing, while others stress skill training; some pay more attention to communicating and conflict solving, while others care more about co-parenting. Overall, positive effects have been proved in those programs, although some of which are not designed rigorously enough nor studied well on their results . This paper proposes that future researchers in China can design intervention programs more suitable for Chinese families; explore and implement some preventive interventions for divorced families; use multiple research methods to explore the effects, active ingredients and mechanism of interventions.

Key words: inter-parental conflict, intervention programs, divorced family, co-parenting, intervention effects

中图分类号:

B849

邓林园, 周佳莹, 周楠, 高诗晴, 李蓓蕾. 父母冲突干预方案及对家庭和儿童青少年的影响[J]. 北京师范大学学报(社会科学版), 2019, 0(6): 32-42.

DENG Linyuan, ZHOU Jiaying, ZHOU Nan, GAO Shiqing, LI Beilei. The Influence of Inter-Parental Conflicts Intervention Programs on Family and Children[J]. Journal of Beijing Normal University(Social Sciences), 2019, 0(6): 32-42.

参考文献

池丽萍,辛自强.(2003).儿童对婚姻冲突的感知量表修订.中国心理卫生杂志,(8),554-556.
付云.(2000).中美城市现代婚姻家庭中的夫妻关系.郑州大学硕士学位论文.
李东阳,王争艳,朱雪娜,梁爱民.(2016).北京市城区儿童祖辈-父母共同养育社区干预研究.中国儿童保健杂志,(6),642-645.
李瑶.(2014).基于幼儿气质特点的“80后”父母消极共同养育行为干预.辽宁师范大学硕士学位论文.
王耘.(1992).美国关于儿童对父母离婚的适应的研究.心理发展与教育,(3),41-44.
吴靖,陈金赞,叶忠根,王治玉.(1990).离婚家庭儿童学习活动的问题及成因.心理发展与教育,6(4),194-202.
张琦妍,李丹.(2015).国内外隔代抚养之痛与对策分析.外国中小学教育,(11),23-28.
Amato,P.R.(1993).Children's adjustment to divorce:Theories,hypotheses,and empirical support.Journal of Marriage and Family, 55(1),23-38.
APA.(2012).Guidelines for the practice of parenting coordination.American Psychologist,67(1),63-71.
Arbuthnot,J.,& Gordon,D.A.(1996).Does mandatory divorce education for parents work？A six-month outcome evaluation.Family Court Review,34(1),60-81.
Arbuthnot,J.,& Gordon,D.A.(2001).What about the children:A guide for divorced and divorcing parents.Athens,OH:The Center for Divorce Education.
Bannon,S.M.,Barle,N.,Mennella,M.S.,O'Leary,K.D.(2018).Parental conflict and college student functioning:Impact of child involvement in conflict.Journal of Divorce and Remarriage,59(3),157-174.
Beach,S.R.H.,Barton,A.W.,Lei,M.K.,Brody,G.H.,Kogan,S.M.,Hurt,T.R.,et al.(2014).The effect of communication change on long-term reductions in child exposure to conflict:Impact of the Promoting Strong African American Families(ProSAAF)Program.Family Process,53(4),580-595.
Bloom,B.L.,& Caldwell,R.A.(1981).Sex differences in adjustment during the process of marital separation.Journal of Marriage and the Family,43(3),693-701.
Bodenmann,G.,& Shantinath,S.D.(2004).The Couples Coping Enhancement Training(CCET):A new approach to prevention of marital distress based upon stress and coping.Family Relations,53(5),477-484.
Braver,S.L.,& Griffin,W.A.(2000).Engaging fathers in the post-divorce family.Marriage and Family Review,29(4),247-267.
Cookston,J.T.,Braver,S.L.,Griffin,W.A.,Lusé,S.R.D.,& Miles,J.C.(2007).Effects of the dads for life intervention on interparental conflict and coparenting in the two years after divorce.Family Process,46(1),123-137.
Cowan,P.A.,& Cowan,C.P.(2014).Controversies in couple relationship education(CRE)overlooked evidence and implications for research and policy.Psychology Public Policy and Law,20(4),361-383.
Cowart,M.A.(2012).The Effects of Intimate Partner Violence on Child Maltreatment Risk:Exploring Moderators and Mediators.Georgia State University.
Cummings,E.M.,El-Sheikh,M.,Kouros,C.D.,& Buckhalt,J.A.(2009).Children and violence:The role of children's regulation in the marital aggression-child adjustment link.Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review,12(1),3-15.
Faircloth,W.B.,& Cummings,E.M.(2008).Evaluating a parent education program for preventing the negative effects of marital conflict.Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology,29(2),141-156.
Faircloth,W.B.,Schermerhorn,A.C.,Mitchell,P.M.,Cummings,J.S.,& Cummings,E.M.(2011).Testing the long-term efficacy of a prevention program for improving marital conflict in community families.Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology,32(4),189-197.
Feinberg,M.E.(2002).Coparenting and the transition to parenthood:A framework for prevention.Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review,5(3),173-195.
Feinberg,M.E.,& Kan,M.L.(2008).Establishing family foundations:Intervention effects on coparenting,parent/infant well-being,and parent-child relations.Journal of Family Psychology,22(2),253-263.
Feinberg,M.E.,Kan,M.L.,& Goslin,M.C.(2009).Enhancing coparenting,parenting,and child self-regulation:Effects of family foundations 1 year after birth.Prevention Science,10(3),276-285.
Garber,B.D.(2004).Directed co-parenting intervention:Conducting child-centered interventions in parallel with highly conflicted co-parents.Professional Psychology Research and Practice,35(1),55-64.
Herman,P.M.,Mahrer,N.E.,Wolchik,S.A.,Porter,M.M.,Jones,S.,& Sandler,I.N.(2015).Cost-benefit analysis of a preventive intervention for divorced families:Reduction in mental health and justice system service use costs 15 years later.Prevention Science,16(4),586-596.
Hetherington,E.M.,Cox,M.,& Cox,R.(1985).Long-term effects of divorce and remarriage on the adjustment of children.Journal of the American Academy of Child Psychiatry,24(5),518-530.
Hetherington,E.M.,& Stanley-Hagan,M.(1999).The adjustment of childrenwith divorced parents:A risk and resiliency perspective.The Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines,40(1),129-140.
Huth-Bocks,A.C.,& Hughes,H.M.(2008).Parenting stress,parenting behavior,and children' s adjustment in families experiencing intimate partner violence.Jouranl of Family Violence,23(4),243-251.
Kramer,K.M.,Arbuthnot,J.,Gordon,D.A.,Rousis,N.J.,& Hoza,J.(1998).Effects of skill-based versus information-based divorce education programs on domestic violence and parental communication.Family Court Review,36(1),9-31.
Kramer,L.,&Washo,C.A.(1993).Evaluation of a court-mandated prevention program for divorcing parents:The children first program.Family Relations,42(2),179-186.
Li,Y.,Cheung,R.Y.M.,& Cummings,E.M.(2015).Marital conflict and emotional insecurity among chinese adolescents:Cultural value moderation.Journal of Research on Adolescence,26(2),316-333.
Martínez-Pampliega,A.,Aguado,V.,Corral,S.,Cormenzana,S.,Merino,L.,& Iriarte,L.(2015).Protecting children after a divorce:Efficacy of Egokitzen—an intervention program for parents on children' s adjustment.Journal of Child and Family Studies,24(12),3782-3792.
Miller-Graff,L.E.,Cummings,E.M.,& Bergman,K.N.(2016).Effects of a brief psychoeducational intervention for family conflict:Constructive conflict,emotional insecurity and child adjustment.Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology,44(7),1399-1410.
Mitcham-Smith,M.,& Henry,W.J.(2007).High-conflict divorce solutions:Parenting coordination as an innovative co-parenting intervention.The Family Journal,15(4),368-373.
Owen,J.,& Rhoades,G.K.(2012).Reducing interparental conflict among parents in contentious child custody disputes:An initial investigation of the Working Together Program.Journal of Marital and Family Therapy,38(3),542-555.
Rhoades,K.A.(2008).Children's responses to interparental conflict:A meta-analysis of their associations with child adjustment.Child Development,79(6),1942-1956.
Shifflett,K.,& Cummings,E.M.(1999).A program for educating parents about the effects of divorce and conflict on children:An initial evaluation.Family Relations,48(1),79-89.
Sun,Y.,& Li,Y.(2002).Children's well-being during parents' marital disruption process:A pooled time-series analysis.Journal of Marriage and Family,64(2),472-488.
The Center for Divorce Education.(2008).Reviews of Children In the Middle(CIM).Retrieved June 20,2008,from:http://www.divorce-education.com/reviews.htm
Tschann,J.M.,Johnston,J.R.,Kline,M.,& Wallerstein,J.S.(1989).Family process and children's functioning during divorce.Journal of Marriage and the Family,51(2),431-444.
Tschann,J.M.,Johnston,J.R.,Kline,M.,Wallerstein,J.S.(1990).Conflict,loss,change and parent-child relationships:Predicting children's adjustment during divorce.Journal of Divorce and Remarriage,13(4),1-22.
Wolchik,S.A.,Sandler,I.N.,Jones,S.,Gonzales,N.,Doyle,K.,Winslow,E.,et al.(2000).The New Beginnings Program for Divorced Families:An experimental evaluation of theory-based single-component and dual-component programs.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,68(5),843-856.
Zemp,M.,Bodenmann,G.,& Cummings,E.M.(2016).The significance of interparental conflict for children:Rationale for couple-focused programs in family therapy.European Psychologist,21(2),99-108.

[1]	赵启, 刘臻臻, 孙晓敏. 薪酬差异与组织创新的关系:风险敏感理论的视角[J]. 北京师范大学学报(社会科学版), 2023, 0(1): 77-85.
[2]	张凤, 黄四林. 社会流动信念:脱贫家庭青少年发展的内生动力[J]. 北京师范大学学报(社会科学版), 2022, 0(3): 140-150.
[3]	苗芃, 谢晓非. 状态无聊对物质主义的影响:意义寻求的中介作用[J]. 北京师范大学学报(社会科学版), 2022, 0(3): 151-160.
[4]	齐亚静, 伍新春. 工作要求—资源模型:理论和实证研究的拓展脉络[J]. 北京师范大学学报(社会科学版), 2018, 0(6): 28-36.